What you’ll explore
What if you add one drop too many? In this lab you titrate vinegar with NaOH until the indicator turns pink and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Where is the jump?. The flask holds 20.0 mL of 0.15 M hydrochloric acid. The burette adds 0.10 M NaOH. At what added volume does the pH shoot up (the equivalence point), in mL?
- Neutral at the end?. Now 25.0 mL of diluted vinegar (0.10 M acetic acid) with 0.10 M NaOH. You stop at exactly the equivalence point, 25.00 mL. What is the pH now?
- Stop on pink. Titrate the 25.0 mL of 0.10 M vinegar with 0.10 M NaOH. Choose where the tap closes so the flask turns pink (pH ≥ 8.2) but you overshoot by no more than 2 drops (≤ 0.10 mL past equivalence).
- What if: one drop too many. Back to 25.0 mL of 0.10 M HCl, titrated with 0.10 M NaOH to exactly 25.00 mL (pH 7). What if one more drop (0.05 mL) falls in? What is the pH then?
- How strong is the vinegar?. 25.0 mL of an unknown diluted vinegar reaches its equivalence point after 20.8 mL of 0.100 M NaOH. What is the acetic acid concentration in the flask, in millimoles per liter (mM)?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Neutralization counts particles, not milliliters: 20.0 mL × 0.15 M = 3.0 mmol of acid needs 3.0 mmol of NaOH, and at 0.10 M that is 30.0 mL. Right there the pH leaps from about 4 to about 10 in a couple of drops.
- At equivalence every acetic acid molecule has become acetate (0.05 M after mixing), and acetate takes H+ back from water: [OH−] = √(Kw/Ka × 0.05) ≈ 5.3 × 10⁻⁶ M, so pH ≈ 8.73. That is why phenolphthalein (pink from 8.2) is the right indicator for vinegar.
- Equivalence is at 25.00 mL. For vinegar the pH at equivalence is already 8.7, so the first lasting pink appears right at it: close the tap at 25.00, 25.05 or 25.10 mL. Real chemists slow to single drops in the last milliliter for exactly this reason.
- The extra drop brings 0.10 M × 0.05 mL = 5 µmol of OH⁻ into 50 mL: [OH⁻] ≈ 1.0 × 10⁻⁴ M, pOH 4, pH 10. One drop moves the pH three whole units, 1000× fewer H⁺ ions. One drop earlier the pH was 4.
- Moles of NaOH at equivalence = 0.100 M × 20.8 mL = 2.08 mmol = moles of acetic acid in 25.0 mL, so C = 2.08 mmol / 25.0 mL = 0.0832 M = 83.2 mM. Undiluted (×10) that is about 0.83 M: 5 % vinegar.
About the model
- pH comes from the exact charge balance of the mixture at 25 °C: [H⁺] + [Na⁺] = [anion] + [OH⁻], with Kw = 1.0 × 10⁻¹⁴ and, for acetic acid, Ka = 1.75 × 10⁻⁵ (pKa 4.76). It is solved for [H⁺] by bisection in log space, so it is exact for the model, not a textbook approximation.
- Ideal dilute solution: concentrations are used instead of activities, volumes simply add, and the temperature stays at 25 °C (the heat of neutralization is ignored).
- NaOH flows in continuously at a steady rate; one burette drop is taken as 0.05 mL. Mixing is instant, so the pH shown is the pH of the whole flask.
- Phenolphthalein is modeled as colourless up to pH 8.2 and fully pink at pH 10, with the color fraction rising linearly in between (drawn with a square-root weight so the first pink is visible; the real dye follows its own acid–base equilibrium; its fading in very strong base above pH 13 is ignored).
- The equivalence volume is measured from the curve itself (its steepest point), the way a chemist reads a titration curve; the checks confirm it matches Ca·Va/Cb.
- Household vinegar is about 5 % acetic acid (≈ 0.83 M); the lab uses it diluted about 8–10× so the volumes stay burette-sized.
- The flask and burette are drawn schematically, and the drops are illustrative: the liquid level and color follow the model.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.