What you’ll explore
Which nail rusts first, and why does zinc protect it? In this lab you three nails in dry air, water and salt water, plus a zinc-coated nail and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Which nail rusts first?. Three plain steel nails for 30 days: tube 1 in dry air, tube 2 in tap water, tube 3 in salt water. Which tube loses the most iron? Type 1, 2 or 3.
- Count the electrons. In rust, Fe(OH)₃, iron is Fe³⁺. How many electrons does each iron atom give to oxygen on its way from the nail to rust?
- Heavier or lighter?. The salt-water nail rusts for 30 days and every flake stays stuck to it. How much does its mass change, in mg? (It loses about 68 mg of iron.)
- Galvanise it. A zinc-coated nail sits in salt water for a full year. Zinc is more reactive than iron, so it gives up its electrons first. Choose the thinnest coating (at most 30 µm) that keeps the iron completely untouched for 365 days.
- What if: copper instead of zinc. Two plain nails in salt water for 30 days; one has a copper wire wrapped around it. Copper is less reactive than iron. How many times more iron does the copper-wrapped nail lose?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Rusting needs water AND oxygen: iron gives electrons to oxygen through the water. Salt water conducts far better than tap water, so the electrons’ round trip is easier and the nail rusts about 4× faster here. Dry air: essentially no rust.
- Fe → Fe³⁺ + 3e⁻. Oxygen takes 4 electrons per O₂, so 4 Fe (12 e⁻) need 3 O₂: 4Fe + 3O₂ + 6H₂O → 4Fe(OH)₃. Electrons given = electrons taken.
- Every iron atom that rusts keeps its place and gains oxygen and water: 55.8 g of Fe becomes 106.9 g of Fe(OH)₃, a gain of 51 g per mole. 68 mg of iron lost → about +62 mg on the scale. Rusting nails get heavier.
- While any zinc is left, oxygen takes its electrons from zinc (Zn → Zn²⁺ + 2e⁻) and the iron is untouched. In salt water the coating thins by about 0.066 µm a day, so one year needs about 24 µm. Real hot-dip galvanising is 45–85 µm.
- Copper gives oxygen extra surface to collect electrons, but it won’t give up its own. Every electron still comes from the iron, which now rusts about 2.1× faster. That’s why plumbers never join copper pipe straight to steel.
About the model
- Rust is simplified to Fe(OH)₃ (real rust is a mix such as FeO(OH) and Fe₂O₃·nH₂O). Overall: 4Fe + 3O₂ + 6H₂O → 4Fe(OH)₃, 3 electrons per iron atom (Fe → Fe²⁺ + 2e⁻, then Fe²⁺ → Fe³⁺ + e⁻), 4 per O₂ (O₂ + 2H₂O + 4e⁻ → 4OH⁻).
- Corrosion speed is set by an illustrative "oxygen demand" current density on bare steel: 0 in dry air, 6 µA/cm² in tap water, 24 µA/cm² in salt water. That gives ≈ 0.05 and ≈ 0.19 mm/yr of steel lost, the usual orders of magnitude for fresh and sea water. Real rates vary a lot with oxygen supply, temperature, stirring and the steel.
- Salt water is faster because dissolved ions make the water conduct, so the electrons’ circuit between rusting spots and oxygen spots is easier. Dry air (no liquid water) is modeled as no rust at all; in humid air steel does rust slowly.
- Zinc coating: zinc (E° −0.76 V) is more reactive than iron (−0.44 V), so while any zinc is left oxygen takes electrons from zinc (Zn → Zn²⁺ + 2e⁻) and the iron is untouched. Zinc’s own corrosion film slows oxygen on its surface; the model takes the zinc rate as 1/15 of the bare-steel demand, ≈ 24 µm/yr in salt water (published sea-water values are roughly 10–30 µm/yr).
- Copper wire (E° +0.34 V) is less reactive: oxygen also collects electrons on the copper surface, but every electron still comes from the iron. The model scales the rate by (iron area + copper area)/iron area ≈ 2.1 for 20 cm of 1 mm wire on a 60 mm × 3 mm nail. Real galvanic effects depend on the area ratio and the water.
- All rust is assumed to stay stuck to the nail (so the nail gets heavier: +51 g per mole of iron, from the oxygen and water). A nail can’t lose more iron than it has (3.34 g); it then stops.
- Drawings are schematic: the zinc layer and the rust are drawn much thicker than real so they can be seen; color and flakes follow the mass of rust.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.