What you’ll explore
What if you cool it fast? A few big crystals, or many tiny ones? In this lab you grow crystals by cooling a saturated solution, slow vs fast and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Fast or slow?. Two beakers of KNO₃ solution, saturated at 60 °C. Blue is cooled fast (10 °C/min), amber slowly (1 °C/min). Does the FAST beaker end with more crystals or fewer? Type 1 for more, −1 for fewer.
- How much comes out?. 100 g of water holds 110 g of KNO₃ at 60 °C (saturated). Cool it to 20 °C, where it can only hold 31.6 g. How many grams of crystals form?
- Grow big crystals. Choose the cooling rate so the beaker ends up with at most 6 crystals.
- What if you add a seed crystal?. Same slow cooling (1 °C/min) as the amber beaker, which grew about 11 crystals. This time you drop in one 3 g seed crystal at the start. How many crystals are there at the end?
- Less water, less cooling. A saturated solution in only 50 g of water at 60 °C is cooled to 40 °C (solubility 63.9 g per 100 g water). How many grams of crystals form?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Crystals grow at a rate set by how supersaturated the solution is. Cool slowly and the first few crystals keep up, so the supersaturation never passes the limit where new crystals are born: about 11 big ones here. Cool fast and it overshoots: about 55 small ones.
- Only the excess leaves the solution: 110 − 31.6 = 78.4 g. The beaker is held at 20 °C until the solution is exactly saturated again, so the crystals end up with precisely that much.
- Only very slow cooling (0.5 °C/min, 80 minutes from 60 to 20 °C) keeps the supersaturation low enough that almost no new crystals are born after the first few. The same 78.4 g then shares out among 6 crystals.
- New crystals are only born once the supersaturation passes a limit (the “metastable zone”). A 3 g seed grows fast enough to keep it below that limit the whole time, so all 78.4 g ends up on one big crystal. This is how large single crystals are grown.
- Per 100 g of water: 110 − 63.9 = 46.1 g. With only 50 g of water, half of that: 23.05 g.
About the model
- KNO₃ solubility from the CRC Handbook (13.3 g per 100 g water at 0 °C, 31.6 at 20 °C, 63.9 at 40 °C, 110 at 60 °C, 246 at 100 °C), with a smooth monotone curve (Fritsch–Carlson cubic) through the 10 °C table points.
- The solution starts exactly saturated at T₀ and cools at a steady rate, then is held at T_end until it is saturated again, so the crystallized mass equals the solubility drop S(T₀) − S(T_end), scaled by the water mass.
- Nucleation: no new crystals below a metastable limit of 2 g KNO₃ per 100 g water of supersaturation; above it, crystals are born at a rate ∝ (σ − 2)². Growth: dm/dt ∝ σ·√m (the surface of a crystal in this 2D picture grows like √mass). The rate constants are illustrative, chosen so the trend is clear; real counts depend on dust, stirring and the vessel.
- The COUNT of new crystals comes from a deterministic accumulator (a crystal appears each time the expected number passes the next whole number); the random seed only sets where they appear and how they point.
- Seen from above as a 2D layer at the bottom of a dish: each crystal is drawn as a flat prism whose area is proportional to its mass (KNO₃ really grows as long prisms/needles). Positions do not move; settling and crystals touching are ignored.
- Temperatures are uniform in the beaker and the heat released by crystallization is ignored. Crystal count doesn’t scale with the water mass in this model (the dish geometry is fixed); only masses do.
- Mean size is the edge of a cube with the mean crystal mass at 2.11 g/cm³, for scale only.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.