What you’ll explore
Why is chlorine’s atomic mass 35.45, not a whole number? In this lab you separate chlorine-35 and chlorine-37 in a mass spectrometer and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Which bends more?. A beam of chlorine ions enters the magnetic field. Chlorine-35 and chlorine-37 have the same charge and the same energy. Which one lands closer to the entrance slit (it bends on a tighter curve)? Type its mass number.
- Why 35.45?. Run 2,500 chlorine ions. About 3 in 4 are chlorine-35 (34.97 u) and 1 in 4 is chlorine-37 (36.97 u). What is the average mass of all the ions that land, in u?
- Hit the detector. The detector slit sits 32.0 cm from the entrance (±2 mm). Set the magnetic field so the chlorine-37 ions land in it.
- What if 2+?. Some chlorine-35 ions lose two electrons instead of one (charge 2+). Same voltage, same field: how big is the 2+ ion’s radius compared with the 1+ ion’s? (Ratio.)
- Real-world check: neon. Neon has three isotopes: neon-20 (90.48%), neon-21 (0.27%) and neon-22 (9.25%). Run 10,000 neon ions. What average mass do they give, in u? (The periodic table says 20.180.)
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- The magnetic force turns every ion, but the lighter one turns more easily: r = √(2mV/q)/B, so r ∝ √m. Chlorine-35 lands at 30.5 cm, chlorine-37 at 31.3 cm: 8 mm apart, enough to count them separately.
- Weighted average: 0.7576 × 34.969 + 0.2424 × 36.966 ≈ 35.45 u. No single chlorine atom weighs 35.45 u; that is the average of the natural mix, which is the number on the periodic table.
- Landing distance = 2r = 2√(2mV/q)/B. To land chlorine-37 at 0.320 m you need B = 2 × √(2 × 36.966 u × 2000 V / e) / 0.320 m ≈ 0.245 T. A stronger field bends every ion tighter.
- r = √(2mV/q)/B, so doubling q divides r by √2: 0.707×. A 2+ chlorine-35 lands where a singly charged ion of mass 17.5 u would, so real spectra label peaks by mass ÷ charge (m/z).
- 0.9048 × 19.992 + 0.0027 × 20.994 + 0.0925 × 21.991 ≈ 20.18 u. This is how the 1913 discovery of isotopes started: J. J. Thomson saw neon split into two beams, 20 and 22.
About the model
- An ideal 180° magnetic-sector mass spectrometer in vacuum: ions leave the source, are accelerated through V (drawn as a short gap, treated as instant), and enter a uniform field B at the entrance slit moving at right angles to it.
- Each ion follows an exact half circle of radius r = √(2mV/q)/B and lands on the detector plate 2r from the slit. An independent RK4 integration of the Lorentz force checks this. Fringe fields, collisions with leftover gas, space charge and the spread of ion energies are ignored.
- Isotope masses and natural abundances are NIST/IUPAC representative values (Cl-35 34.969 u, 75.76%; Cl-37 36.966 u, 24.24%; C-13 1.07%; Ne-20/21/22 90.48/0.27/9.25%). Real samples vary slightly, which is why IUPAC gives some atomic weights as ranges.
- Which isotope each ion is comes from a fixed low-discrepancy sequence, so after N ions every count is within about 1 of N × abundance (a real beam is random and would scatter by about √N).
- The beam is drawn in real proportions but slowed about a million times: a chlorine ion swings round in about 4.6 µs. Ions and the landing bars are drawn much larger than real so they can be seen.
- The 2+ ions (two electrons removed) are accelerated to twice the energy and feel twice the force; the net effect is r ∝ 1/√q. Real spectra plot peaks by mass ÷ charge (m/z).
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.