What you’ll explore
Which fuel carries the most energy per kilogram? In this lab you design a fuel: compare methane, propane, ethanol and hydrogen and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Energy per gram: hydrogen. Burn 1 g of hydrogen (H₂, 2.016 g/mol, ΔH_c = −285.8 kJ/mol). How much energy does each gram release, in kJ/g?
- Carbon cost of methane. Methane burns as CH₄ + 2 O₂ → CO₂ + 2 H₂O and releases 890.3 kJ per mole. How many grams of CO₂ does it make for each megajoule (1000 kJ) of heat?
- Camp stove: heat 1 L by 60 °C. A camp stove burns propane (C₃H₈, 44.1 g/mol, 2219.9 kJ/mol) under 1 L of water at 20 °C. Only 40 % of the heat reaches the water. Choose the mass of propane that warms it by 60 °C (± 1 °C).
- What if we count liters?. At room temperature and pressure, ethanol is a liquid (0.789 g/mL) and hydrogen is a gas (24.47 L/mol). How many liters of hydrogen gas carry the same energy as 1 L of ethanol?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- 1 g ÷ 2.016 g/mol = 0.496 mol, and 0.496 × 285.8 ≈ 141.8 kJ. That is about 2.6× methane (55.5 kJ/g) and 4.8× ethanol (29.7 kJ/g): hydrogen is the lightest fuel there is, so each gram carries the most energy.
- One mole of CH₄ makes one mole of CO₂ (44.0 g) and 890.3 kJ. Per MJ: 44.0 ÷ 0.8903 ≈ 49.4 g of CO₂. Propane is ≈ 59.5 g/MJ, ethanol ≈ 64.4 g/MJ and hydrogen 0: it has no carbon.
- The water needs 1000 g × 4.186 J/(g·°C) × 60 °C = 251 kJ. Each gram of propane gives 50.3 kJ, but only 40 % arrives: 20.1 kJ/g. So m ≈ 251 ÷ 20.1 ≈ 12.5 g, a small canister’s worth of gas.
- 1 L of ethanol is 789 g × 29.7 kJ/g ≈ 23,400 kJ. A liter of hydrogen gas is 1/24.47 mol × 285.8 kJ ≈ 11.7 kJ. So you need about 2,000 L of hydrogen gas: the best fuel per kilogram is the worst per liter. That is why hydrogen cars squeeze it to about 700 bar.
About the model
- Standard enthalpies of combustion at 25 °C with liquid water as product (higher heating values; NIST/CRC): CH₄ 890.3, C₃H₈ 2219.9, C₂H₅OH 1366.8, H₂ 285.8 kJ/mol. A flame makes steam, so the usable (lower) heating value is ≈ 10 % lower for methane and ≈ 15 % lower for hydrogen; the efficiency slider covers this and all other losses.
- Molar masses from IUPAC standard atomic weights (C 12.011, H 1.008, O 15.999). Combustion is complete: CxHyOz + (x + y/4 − z/2) O₂ → x CO₂ + y/2 H₂O. No CO or soot.
- Per-liter figures are for the fuel as it is at 25 °C and 1 atm: methane, propane and hydrogen as ideal gases (24.465 L/mol), ethanol as a liquid (0.789 g/mL). Bottled propane is a liquid under pressure (≈ 0.49 kg/L, ≈ 25 MJ/L) and car hydrogen is compressed to ≈ 700 bar (≈ 5 MJ/L), both far better than at 1 atm.
- Each pot holds the stated mass of water with c = 4.186 J/(g·°C); the pot itself has no heat capacity. At 100 °C further heat boils water off at 2257 J/g; if a pot boils dry, the rest of the heat is shown as escaped.
- Fuel burns at a steady rate for the burn time; flame size is drawn in proportion to heat output. Fuel "cubes" show the true volume of the fuel at 25 °C and 1 atm (drawn at most 0.5 m wide; the label gives the real volume).
- The hydrogen flame is drawn faint because it is nearly invisible in daylight. Energy per gram and CO₂ per MJ labels appear only after a run, so the scene never gives away a level answer.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.