What you’ll explore
Same mass, same push. Why does one rotor spin up 3× slower? In this lab you spin up two rotors: same mass, balls near the axle vs far out and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Same balls, farther out. Two 0.5 kg balls move from 10 cm to 30 cm from the axle. How many times bigger does their moment of inertia (Σ m·r²) get?
- The race. Same rotor, same 0.5 kg weight, same 1 m drop. Rig A has its balls at 5 cm (lands in 1.73 s). Rig B has them at 30 cm. How long does rig B’s weight take to reach the floor, in seconds?
- How fast does it spin up?. Rig A (balls at 5 cm) is driven by the 0.5 kg weight through a 4 cm hub. What is the rotor’s angular acceleration, in rad/s²?
- Tune the rotor. Slide rig B’s balls in or out so its weight takes 3.0 s (±0.1 s) to fall the 1 m.
- Where did the energy go?. Rig B (balls at 30 cm): when its weight reaches the floor, what percent of the energy the weight released is now spinning the rotor?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- I = Σ m·r². Three times the distance gives 3² = 9 times the moment of inertia, with exactly the same mass.
- a = m·g ÷ (m + I/r²). Rig B: I = 0.098 kg·m², so I/r² ≈ 61.5 kg of “effective mass”: a ≈ 0.079 m/s² and t = √(2h/a) ≈ 5.03 s, almost 3 times slower.
- The string pulls with T = m(g − a) ≈ 4.57 N at r = 4 cm, so τ = T·r ≈ 0.183 N·m. α = τ/I = 0.183 ÷ 0.0109 ≈ 16.7 rad/s², the same as a/r.
- For t = 3 s you need a = 2h/t² ≈ 0.222 m/s², so I = (m·g/a − m)·r² ≈ 0.0345 kg·m². Subtract the rod and the balls’ own spin, then 2·m·R² gives R ≈ 16 cm.
- Weight and rotor share one speed through the string, so the energy splits as m : I/r² = 0.5 : 61.5. The rotor takes about 99% and the weight lands at only 0.40 m/s.
About the model
- Rotor: a 0.2 kg, 0.7 m rod (I = M·L²/12) plus two solid steel balls (25 mm radius) clamped at radius R; each ball adds ⅖·m·b² + m·R² (parallel-axis theorem). The axle, hub and clamps are treated as massless; the axle and pulley have no friction; no air drag.
- The string is massless and inextensible and unwinds from a hub of radius r (4 cm by default) over a light pulley to the hanging weight: a = m·g ÷ (m + I/r²), α = a/r, T = m(g − a), τ = T·r.
- Both rigs start at rest. When a weight reaches the floor it stops and the string goes slack, so the rotor coasts at constant ω (frictionless). The run ends 1 s after the slower weight lands.
- Blue = rig A, amber = rig B; they are identical except for R. The balls are drawn 1.8× their real 25 mm radius so they are visible; distances are otherwise to scale.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.