What you’ll explore
Same ramp, same height. Who wins? In this lab you race a solid ball, a disc, a hoop and a sliding box down the same ramp and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Who wins?. A solid ball, a disc and a hoop (same mass, same radius) roll down the same 3 m ramp at 20°. Which roller reaches the bottom first? Type 1 for the ball, 2 for the disc, 3 for the hoop.
- How much slower?. Same race. How many times longer does the hoop take than the solid ball to reach the bottom? (e.g. 1.5)
- Speed at the bottom. The disc rolls 3 m down the 20° ramp (a drop of about 1.03 m). How fast is it moving at the bottom, in m/s? (g = 9.81 m/s²)
- Steepest roll. The ramp surface gives μ = 0.2. Set the steepest angle at which the disc still rolls without slipping (to within 1°).
- Bigger and heavier. What if one ball is 5 times heavier and twice as big? How many seconds sooner does the big ball reach the bottom? (Type 0 if they tie.)
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Rolling objects share their energy between moving and spinning. The ball (I = ⅖mR²) spends the least on spin, so it wins; the hoop (I = mR²) spends the most and comes last. The frictionless box, which doesn’t spin at all, beats them all.
- t = √(2L(1 + k)/(g sinθ)), so the ratio is √((1 + 1)/(1 + 0.4)) = √(1.43) ≈ 1.20. Nothing else matters: not the ramp length, the angle, the mass or the radius.
- Energy: mgh = ½mv² + ½Iω² with I = ½mR² and ω = v/R, so mgh = ¾mv² and v = √(2gh/1.5) ≈ 3.66 m/s.
- Rolling needs friction f = mg sinθ · k/(1 + k), and static friction gives at most μ·mg cosθ. So tanθ ≤ μ(1 + k)/k = 0.2 × 3 = 0.6, θ ≤ 31.0°. The hoop (k = 1) slips first: it needs tanθ ≤ 2μ.
- They tie. a = g sinθ/(1 + I/mR²) and I/mR² = ⅖ for every solid ball, so mass and radius cancel: only the shape (how the mass is spread) matters.
About the model
- Rigid, ideal shapes rolling on a flat rigid ramp: solid ball I = ⅖mR², solid disc I = ½mR², thin hoop I = mR². No rolling resistance, no air drag. g = 9.81 m/s².
- The box is a frictionless slider (k = 0): the reference for "all the energy goes into moving". A box with friction would be slower; here it stands for zero spin.
- Friction: one coefficient μ for both static and kinetic friction (a simplification). Rolling needs friction f = mg sinθ·k/(1+k); a roller slips when tanθ > μ(1+k)/k, then kinetic friction μN both slows its slide and spins it up.
- All objects start from rest at the same line and travel the same distance along the ramp. Each lane has constant accelerations, so the motion is computed exactly (no step-size error). After arriving, a lane shows its arrival speed.
- The objects are drawn larger than their true radius so the spin is visible; the physics uses the true radius (and radius cancels anyway).
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.