Bops Lab
Daily Lab

Rolling down a ramp

Race a solid ball, a disc, a hoop and a sliding box down the same ramp

Bops Lab

What you’ll explore

Same ramp, same height. Who wins? In this lab you race a solid ball, a disc, a hoop and a sliding box down the same ramp and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.

Challenge levels

  1. Who wins?. A solid ball, a disc and a hoop (same mass, same radius) roll down the same 3 m ramp at 20°. Which roller reaches the bottom first? Type 1 for the ball, 2 for the disc, 3 for the hoop.
  2. How much slower?. Same race. How many times longer does the hoop take than the solid ball to reach the bottom? (e.g. 1.5)
  3. Speed at the bottom. The disc rolls 3 m down the 20° ramp (a drop of about 1.03 m). How fast is it moving at the bottom, in m/s? (g = 9.81 m/s²)
  4. Steepest roll. The ramp surface gives μ = 0.2. Set the steepest angle at which the disc still rolls without slipping (to within 1°).
  5. Bigger and heavier. What if one ball is 5 times heavier and twice as big? How many seconds sooner does the big ball reach the bottom? (Type 0 if they tie.)

Key ideas

Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
  • Rolling objects share their energy between moving and spinning. The ball (I = ⅖mR²) spends the least on spin, so it wins; the hoop (I = mR²) spends the most and comes last. The frictionless box, which doesn’t spin at all, beats them all.
  • t = √(2L(1 + k)/(g sinθ)), so the ratio is √((1 + 1)/(1 + 0.4)) = √(1.43) ≈ 1.20. Nothing else matters: not the ramp length, the angle, the mass or the radius.
  • Energy: mgh = ½mv² + ½Iω² with I = ½mR² and ω = v/R, so mgh = ¾mv² and v = √(2gh/1.5) ≈ 3.66 m/s.
  • Rolling needs friction f = mg sinθ · k/(1 + k), and static friction gives at most μ·mg cosθ. So tanθ ≤ μ(1 + k)/k = 0.2 × 3 = 0.6, θ ≤ 31.0°. The hoop (k = 1) slips first: it needs tanθ ≤ 2μ.
  • They tie. a = g sinθ/(1 + I/mR²) and I/mR² = ⅖ for every solid ball, so mass and radius cancel: only the shape (how the mass is spread) matters.

About the model

Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.