What you’ll explore
Tiny pushes, huge swing. Why does timing beat strength? In this lab you push a swing: timing vs strength and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- The swing’s own rhythm. One push, then let it swing. The ropes are 2.5 m long. How long does one full swing take (forward and back), in seconds?
- Ten pushes in rhythm. Each push adds just 0.2 m/s. You push 10 times, exactly once per swing, always as it passes the bottom moving forward. No friction. How fast is it going at the bottom after the 10th push, in m/s?
- Which rhythm wins?. Blue is pushed every 3.17 s (its own rhythm), amber every 2.5 s. Same 12 tiny pushes each, no friction. How many times bigger is blue’s biggest swing than amber’s?
- Find the rhythm. With a little friction, give 12 pushes. Choose the time between pushes that makes the swing as big as possible (at least 90% of the best).
- What if there is more friction?. Now a smooth push at exactly the swing’s rhythm. Amber has 4× more friction (damping) than blue. Once both have settled, how big is amber’s swing compared with blue’s (as a fraction)?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- A swing is a pendulum: T = 2π√(L/g) = 2π√(2.5 / 9.81) ≈ 3.17 s, whoever sits on it and however high it goes (for small swings). Friction changes it by less than 0.01%.
- Pushed in rhythm, every push arrives when the swing is back at the bottom moving forward, so the speeds simply add: 10 × 0.2 = 2.0 m/s. Tiny pushes, big swing.
- Blue’s 12 pushes all add up (12 × 0.2 m/s). Amber’s drift out of step: after a few pushes they start landing while it moves backwards and cancel. Its biggest swing is only about 1/7 of blue’s.
- Push once per natural period, T = 2π√(L/g) ≈ 3.17 s. Then every push lands as the swing passes the bottom moving forward. Off by even a few tenths of a second and the pushes start to fight the swing.
- At resonance the push’s energy is balanced only by friction, so the settled swing is A = F0/(m·γ·ω0): 4× the damping gives ¼ of the swing. More damping makes the resonance peak lower and wider.
About the model
- Each swing is a pendulum of rope length L (2.5 m) in the small-angle limit: a linear damped oscillator along the arc, s″ + γ·s′ + (g/L)·s = F/m. Beyond about 30° the real swing is slightly slower; the HUD marks such swings with *.
- Hand pushes are instant impulses of J = 6 N·s on a 30 kg rider (each adds 0.2 m/s), one every Td seconds from t = 0. Between pushes the motion is the exact damped solution, so the time step never matters.
- The smooth push is F0·cos(2πt/Td) from t = 0; the swing is the exact start-up plus steady-state solution. For the smooth push the damping is capped at γ ≥ 0.01/s so the swing stays finite at resonance.
- Damping γ lumps air drag and friction at the hooks into one linear term. Real swings lose energy a little faster at large angles.
- The graph shows the textbook steady-state response to a smooth push, A(ω) = (F0/m)/√((ω0²−ω²)² + (γω)²), relative to a steady push; hand pushes also build up best at the swing’s own rhythm (and every second swing).
- Real-world notes: soldiers break step on bridges to avoid driving a bridge mode in rhythm. The Tacoma Narrows collapse (1940) was aeroelastic flutter, a self-exciting wind effect, not simple forced resonance.
- Riders are abstract capsules; the push arrow is drawn for a moment after each push, not to scale.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.