What you’ll explore
What if you add a lone pair? Why is water bent? In this lab you let electron groups push apart: CO₂, BF₃, CH₄, NH₃ and H₂O and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Four bonds. Methane (CH₄): carbon has four bonds and no lone pairs. Let the four electron domains push apart. What is the H–C–H angle, in degrees?
- Why water is bent. Water (H₂O): oxygen has two bonds and two lone pairs. What is the H–O–H angle, in degrees?
- Find 120°. No lone pairs. How many bonds must the central atom have so that every bond angle is 120°?
- What if one bond becomes a lone pair?. What if one of methane’s four bonds is replaced by a lone pair (that’s ammonia, NH₃)? What is the new H–N–H angle, in degrees?
- What if lone pairs were no bigger than bonds?. What if lone pairs pushed exactly as hard as bonds (lone-pair size 1.0)? What would water’s H–O–H angle be, in degrees?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Four domains spread to the corners of a tetrahedron: every H–C–H angle is 109.5° (cos θ = −1/3), more than the 90° of a flat cross.
- Four domains (2 bonds + 2 lone pairs) point roughly to a tetrahedron’s corners, so water is bent. The lone pairs are fatter than bonds and squeeze the angle from 109.5° to about 104.5°, the measured value.
- Three domains spread into a flat triangle: 360° ÷ 3 = 120° between every pair (like BF₃). Five domains also have some 120° angles, but their other angles are 90° and 180°.
- Still four domains, so still roughly tetrahedral, but the fat lone pair squeezes the bonds: this model gives about 107° (measured: 107.8°). Now the molecule is a pyramid.
- With equal domains, four of anything make a regular tetrahedron: 109.5°. Real water is 104.5°, which is how we know lone pairs take up more room than bonds.
About the model
- Model: each electron group (a bond, or a lone pair) is a point on a sphere around the central atom. Groups repel with energy q₁q₂/d² (d = distance between points), and relax by gradient descent from a lopsided starting cluster to the lowest-energy arrangement. This is the VSEPR idea as a toy model, not a quantum calculation.
- Double bonds (as in CO₂) count as one group, like a single bond.
- Lone pairs are given a larger “size” (q = 1.2835 vs 1 for a bond), calibrated so water comes out at 104.5° (measured 104.5°). With that one number the model gives NH₃ 106.8° (measured 107.8°) and SO₂ ≈114.5° (measured 119°): the direction is right, the exact values are the model’s.
- With lone pairs the relaxation is started from every choice of which starting points are lone pairs (at most 10), and the lowest-energy result is shown. The lab caps lone-pair molecules at 5 electron groups: this simple repulsion model does not reproduce the 6-group lone-pair shapes (BrF₅ square pyramidal, XeF₄ square planar).
- Balloons show the space each group takes (lone pairs fatter); bond lengths and atom sizes are for display only. The molecule turns slowly so its 3D shape is visible.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.