What you’ll explore
Why does salt form perfect cubes? In this lab you grow a salt crystal: Na⁺ and Cl⁻ ions attract and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Handing over the electron. Pulling the outer electron off sodium costs 5.14 eV. Chlorine gives back 3.61 eV when it takes it. What is the net energy change of the transfer alone, in eV? (+ means it costs energy.)
- Snap together. A Na⁺ and a Cl⁻ start far apart and settle at their bond length, 2.36 Å. How much energy is released in total, in eV? (Run it and read the potential energy at the end.)
- Where the pull stops. Set the starting distance so that, when you let go, the net force on the ions is (almost) zero: they just sit there.
- Many neighbors. In a salt crystal every ion feels all the others: 6 opposite neighbors pull, the next 12 (same charge) push, and so on. Adding them all up, the crystal’s pull on one ion is how many times a single neighbor’s?
- What if the charges double?. What if we swap to magnesium oxide: Mg²⁺ and O²⁻ in the same cubic lattice, 2.11 Å apart instead of 2.81 Å? How many times larger is its lattice energy than table salt’s?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- 5.14 − 3.61 = +1.53 eV: the transfer alone costs energy. Ionic compounds still form because the + and − ions then pull together and release much more than that.
- At 2.36 Å the attraction k/r = 6.10 eV is partly canceled by the clouds’ repulsion (0.83 eV), leaving 5.27 eV. That is far more than the 1.53 eV the electron transfer cost.
- Farther out, attraction wins and they pull in; closer in, the electron clouds overlap and push apart. At 2.36 Å the two forces cancel: that distance is the bond length.
- Summing shell after shell (Evjen’s method) settles at 1.748, the Madelung constant of the rock-salt lattice. The crystal binds each ion 1.75× more strongly than one isolated neighbor would.
- Charges ±2 give 4× the attraction; the shorter spacing (2.81 → 2.11 Å) multiplies that by 1.34. About 5.2× in total, which is why MgO melts at 2852 °C and salt at 801 °C.
About the model
- Pair mode follows one Na⁺ and one Cl⁻ along the line joining them, with U(r) = −k/r + A·e^(−r/ρ): Coulomb attraction (k = 14.40 eV·Å) plus Born–Mayer repulsion when the electron clouds overlap (ρ = 0.321 Å, A set so the minimum sits at the gas-phase NaCl bond length, 2.36 Å). This gives a bond energy of 5.27 eV (measured ≈ 5.6 eV to separate into ions) and a vibration of 338 cm⁻¹ (measured 366 cm⁻¹).
- The electron transfer is not animated: it is counted as IE(Na) − EA(Cl) = 5.139 − 3.613 = +1.53 eV (NIST). Ions start at rest.
- A damping term hands energy to the surroundings (the "heat" readout), so the pair settles. A lone molecule in a vacuum would keep vibrating; in real salt the neighbors take the energy up. Kinetic + potential + heat always equals the starting energy.
- Crystal mode: the 125-ion block assembling from scattered ions is illustrative (inner ions first, positions eased along straight lines), not a simulation of crystal growth. The Madelung sum is computed properly with Evjen’s weighted cubes and reaches 1.747565 at 16 shells (literature 1.7475646).
- Lattice energies use the Born–Landé formula U = 1389 kJ·Å/mol × M·z²/r₀ × (1 − 1/n), with measured spacings r₀ and Born exponents n (NaCl 8, KCl 9, LiF 6, MgO 7). They land within 5% of the Born–Haber values shown as "measured".
- Ions are drawn at 60% of their ionic radii so both stay visible at the gas-phase bond length; distances and arrows are not otherwise to scale. Time in pair mode is in femtoseconds (10⁻¹⁵ s).
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.