Bops Lab
Daily Lab

Polarity

Shake oil and water, then look inside their molecules

Bops Lab

What you’ll explore

Oil and water don’t mix because oil is lighter? Not quite. In this lab you shake oil and water, then look inside their molecules and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.

Challenge levels

  1. Two polar bonds. Carbon dioxide has two strongly polar C=O bonds (2.3 D each). What is the whole molecule’s dipole, in debye (D)?
  2. The bent one. Water’s two O–H bonds are 1.51 D each and meet at 104.5°. What is the water molecule’s dipole, in debye?
  3. How different must they be?. The mismatch ε is how much more water sticks to water than to oil (in units of kT). Set the smallest mismatch that still makes a shaken 50/50 mixture separate (demix index ≥ 0.70). Keep it at 1.3 kT or less.
  4. What if oil were as heavy as water?. Make the oil exactly as dense as water (no buoyancy) and shake. Do they still separate? Type 1 for yes, 0 for no.

Key ideas

Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
  • A dipole is a vector: size AND direction. CO₂ is straight, so its two equal C=O dipoles pull in opposite directions and add to exactly 0 D. CO₂ is a non-polar molecule made of polar bonds.
  • The sideways parts of the two O–H dipoles cancel; the parts along the molecule’s axis add: 2 × 1.51 × cos 52.25° ≈ 1.85 D, pointing toward the oxygen (the δ− end). That makes water strongly polar.
  • Below about ε ≈ 0.9 kT the random jiggling of heat wins and the liquids stay mixed. Above it, the energy saved by keeping like next to like wins and the mixture splits. For a very large 50/50 lattice the theory gives the sharp value ε = ln(1 + √2) ≈ 0.88 kT.
  • They still separate, into blobs instead of two layers. Water molecules are polar and cling to each other; oil can’t join in, so it gets squeezed out. Density only decides which layer floats to the top once the separation has happened.

About the model

Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.