What you’ll explore
Why does one tube fill twice as fast as the other? In this lab you split water with a battery in a Hofmann voltameter and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Two tubes, one current. A battery drives 1.0 A through water for 5 minutes. Hydrogen collects over one electrode and oxygen over the other. How many times more hydrogen than oxygen do you collect, by volume?
- How much hydrogen?. 1.00 A for 10 minutes, gas at 25 °C and 1 atm (24.47 L per mole). Faraday constant 96,485 C/mol. How many milliliters of hydrogen do you collect?
- 50 mL in 5 minutes. Set the current so the hydrogen tube reaches 50 mL (± 1 mL) in exactly 5 minutes (25 °C, 1 atm).
- What if: double the voltage. Same cell, same 1.00 A for 10 minutes, but the supply is turned up from 2 V to 4 V (the current is held at 1.00 A). How many milliliters of hydrogen now?
- Where does the energy go?. At 2.0 V, what percentage of the electrical energy ends up stored in the hydrogen (its heat of combustion, 285.8 kJ/mol)?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Water is H₂O: two hydrogens for every oxygen. Every 4 electrons make 2 H₂ at one electrode and 1 O₂ at the other, and equal moles of gas take equal volumes. So the hydrogen tube fills exactly twice as fast.
- Charge = 1.00 A × 600 s = 600 C = 600 / 96,485 = 6.22 mmol of electrons. Two electrons per H₂ gives 3.11 mmol, and 3.11 mmol × 24.47 L/mol ≈ 76.1 mL. The oxygen tube has half that, 38.0 mL.
- 50 mL is 50 / 24,470 = 2.04 mmol of H₂, which needs 4.09 mmol of electrons = 394 C. Spread over 300 s that is 394 / 300 ≈ 1.31 A.
- Still 76.1 mL. Faraday’s law only cares about charge: 1 A × 600 s. Doubling the voltage doubles the energy you pay (4.8 kJ instead of 2.4 kJ), and all the extra ends up as heat in the water.
- Each mole of H₂ carries 285.8 kJ and needs 2 × 96,485 C, i.e. 1.48 J per coulomb (1.48 V). At 2.0 V you pay 2.0 J per coulomb, so 1.48 / 2.0 = 74% is stored and 26% becomes heat. At 4 V only 37% is stored.
About the model
- Faraday’s law with 100% current efficiency: every electron makes product (n(H₂) = It/2F, n(O₂) = It/4F). Real cells lose a little to side reactions and to gas dissolving in the water; oxygen is noticeably more soluble, so real O₂ tubes often read a bit under half.
- Gas volumes use the ideal gas law at the chosen temperature and pressure (default 25 °C, 1 atm → 24.47 L/mol). Water vapor in the collected gas and the hydrostatic pressure of the water column in the tube are ignored.
- Voltages: the reversible minimum is ΔG°/2F = 1.23 V; below it the model passes no current. The thermoneutral voltage ΔH°/2F = 1.48 V is the energy the hydrogen gives back when burned (its higher heating value, 285.8 kJ/mol). "Stored in H₂" = 1.48 V / V; between 1.23 and 1.48 V the cell draws the difference as heat from the water.
- The current is set directly (as with a lab power supply in constant-current mode). In a real cell the current at a given voltage depends on the electrolyte and the electrodes; practical cells need about 1.8–2 V.
- The water contains a little electrolyte (for example sodium sulfate) so it conducts; the electrolyte is not consumed.
- Bubbles are drawn for visibility: their number follows the gas rate, not a real bubble count; the tube scale is set so the run fits the tube.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.