What you’ll explore
A burning candle loses mass. Is the matter destroyed? In this lab you burn a candle and a gas flame on a scale: where does the mass go? and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- The sealed jar. A candle stands inside a glass jar with the lid screwed on, and the whole jar sits on a scale. The candle burns 1.0 g of wax. By how many grams does the scale reading change? (Use a minus sign for a drop.)
- Where the carbon goes. A gas burner burns 16 g of methane (CH₄ + 2 O₂ → CO₂ + 2 H₂O) with plenty of air. How many grams of carbon dioxide does it make? (Molar masses: CH₄ 16.04 g/mol, CO₂ 44.01 g/mol.)
- Make the flame blue. The burner’s air hole sets the oxygen supply. Too little oxygen gives a sooty yellow flame and poisonous carbon monoxide. Choose the smallest oxygen supply that still burns the methane completely (a clean blue flame).
- What if the lid is off?. Same candle, same 1.0 g of wax, but now the jar is open at the top. By how many grams does the scale reading change?
- Heat from one gram. Methane releases 890 kJ per mole when it burns completely. How many kilojoules does 1.0 g of methane release? (Molar mass 16.04 g/mol.)
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Burning rearranges atoms; it never removes them. The wax’s carbon and hydrogen combine with oxygen from the air in the jar to make CO₂ and water. All of it stays under the lid, so the scale doesn’t move at all.
- 16 g of methane is 1 mol. Each CH₄ gives one CO₂, so you get 1 mol of CO₂ = 44 g. The extra mass is oxygen taken from the air: 16 g of methane plus 64 g of oxygen becomes 44 g of CO₂ plus 36 g of water.
- CH₄ + 2 O₂ → CO₂ + 2 H₂O: every methane needs two oxygen molecules. Below that, hydrogen still grabs its oxygen first, and the carbon ends up as CO or soot, which glows yellow. At 1× (2 O₂ per CH₄) or more, all the carbon becomes CO₂ and the flame burns blue.
- The reading drops by exactly the 1.0 g of wax burned. The products (3.1 g of CO₂ and 1.3 g of water vapor) are heavier than the wax, but they float out of the open jar. That’s why a burning candle seems to “lose” mass.
- 1.0 g is 1/16.04 of a mole, so the heat is 890 ÷ 16.04 ≈ 55.5 kJ. That’s why natural gas is such a good fuel: gram for gram it beats wood (about 16 kJ) and candle wax (about 47 kJ).
About the model
- Fuels: methane CH₄ (burner) and candle wax treated as pure n-pentacosane C₂₅H₅₂ (real paraffin is a mix of C₂₀–C₄₀ alkanes). Standard atomic weights H 1.008, C 12.011, O 15.999, N 14.007.
- The burner consumes the set mass of fuel at a steady rate over 8 s (a teaching pace, not a real burning rate). All amounts grow linearly with this progress, so C, H and O atoms balance at every instant.
- Oxygen supply λ = O₂ supplied ÷ O₂ needed for complete burning. With λ < 1 the model gives oxygen to hydrogen first (→ H₂O), then carbon (C → CO → CO₂). Real flames make a mixture of products at any λ; this ordered split is a simplification that gets the trend right (less O₂ → CO, then soot). λ is kept between 0.5 and 3: below about half the needed oxygen a real flame goes out.
- Flame color: blue when a gas flame burns completely; orange when CO forms; yellow (glowing soot) when carbon is left over. A candle is shown yellow even with plenty of air: its soot glows in the flame and then burns away, so its products are still CO₂ and water. This is qualitative.
- Heat released from Hess’s law with ΔHf (kJ/mol): CO₂ −393.5, CO −110.5, H₂O(l) −285.8, CH₄ −74.8, C₂₅H₅₂(s) −743 (estimated from alkane group values). This gives 890 kJ/mol = 55.5 kJ/g for methane and 46.9 kJ/g for wax (paraffin literature: about 46 kJ/g). Water is counted as liquid (higher heating value).
- Sealed jar: its air holds exactly the oxygen the flame is fed plus the nitrogen that comes with it (79 : 21). A real candle in a sealed jar goes out at about 15 % O₂, before the oxygen is used up; the mass argument is unchanged. Open jar: all hot products (including soot) rise out and leave the scale; the oxygen comes from the room, which is not on the scale.
- The scale reads jar + burner stand (520 g) + fuel; for methane the gas cartridge feeding the burner sits on the scale too. 10 g of fuel always stays in the burner (it is not burned), so the burner never looks empty.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.