What you’ll explore
Is the crown pure gold? Archimedes found out without melting it. In this lab you test the king’s crown: weigh it in air and in water and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Pure gold, under water. A pure gold crown weighs 9.81 N (1 kg) on the scale. Lower it completely into water. What does the scale read now, in N?
- Two readings, one density. The king’s crown reads 9.81 N in air and 9.17 N fully under water. What is its density, in kg/m³? (Pure gold is 19,300.)
- How much silver?. A 1 kg crown reads 9.20 N under water. Set the silver share of the crown so the scale shows the same reading.
- Why weigh it?. The legend says Archimedes measured the overflowing water. A 1 kg crown with 10% silver and a 1 kg gold bar go into brim-full cans. How many more milliliters does the crown’s can overflow?
- Does the shape matter?. A pure gold crown and a pure gold bar, 1 kg each, both fully under water. How many grams more does the bar read than the crown?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Gold is 19.3× denser than water, so 1 kg of gold has a volume of 51.8 cm³ and pushes aside 51.8 g of water. Buoyancy = 0.0518 kg × 9.81 = 0.51 N, so the scale reads 9.81 − 0.51 = 9.30 N.
- The weight lost in water (9.81 − 9.17 = 0.64 N) is the weight of water with the crown’s volume. Density = 1000 × 9.81 / 0.64 ≈ 15,400 kg/m³: well below gold’s 19,300. It is about 30% silver by mass.
- Silver is lighter than gold (10,500 vs 19,300 kg/m³), so every bit of silver adds volume and buoyancy. 9.20 N means a density of about 16,100 kg/m³: roughly 24% silver.
- About 4.3 mL: less than a teaspoon, easy to lose in spills and drips. The scale sees the same difference as 4.3 g less on a 1 kg reading, which a good balance catches easily. That is why Galileo argued Archimedes probably weighed it.
- Same mass of the same metal means the same volume, so the same buoyancy: both read 948.2 g. Only density decides the underwater reading.
About the model
- Scales read in grams-force (reading ÷ 9.81 × 1000). Gold 19,300 kg/m³, silver 10,500 kg/m³, fresh water 1,000 kg/m³.
- The crown is an ideal alloy: volumes add (V = m_gold/ρ_gold + m_silver/ρ_silver). Real gold–silver alloys shrink very slightly on mixing; ignored.
- The crown is a thin band with 8 triangular points (a flat-panel approximation of a curved crown); the wall thickness is solved so the metal volume is exactly m/ρ. The gold bar is a 4 × 2 cm block.
- Lowering is slow (2 cm/s), so the reading is quasi-static: water drag, waves and surface tension on the string are ignored, and the string’s own volume is neglected.
- The overflow cans start brim-full: the water surface stays at the spout, and the cup catches exactly the submerged volume.
- History: the overflow story comes from Vitruvius, two centuries later. Galileo (La Bilancetta, 1586) argued Archimedes more likely used a balance in water, as the scales here do.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.