What you’ll explore
The clay sticks. Is momentum conserved? (Not the kind you think.) In this lab you throw a lump of clay at a hanging rod and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Clay sticks. A 0.1 kg lump of clay at 8 m/s hits a 1.2 kg, 1 m rod 0.8 m below its pivot and sticks. How fast is the clay moving just after the hit, in m/s?
- Where the energy went. Same hit: the clay sticks at 0.8 m. What percentage of the clay’s kinetic energy is lost in the collision?
- Find the sweet spot. Move the impact point so the pivot feels (almost) no kick: the pivot impulse must be under 0.01 N·s.
- What if it bounces. What if a 0.1 kg rubber ball bounces perfectly (e = 1) off the same point, 0.8 m down, at 8 m/s? How fast does the rod spin just after, in rad/s?
- The pivot pushes. Back to the clay at 0.8 m. How big is the impulse from the pivot during the hit, in N·s (positive = in the clay’s direction)?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Only angular momentum about the pivot is conserved: 0.1 × 8 × 0.8 = (0.4 + 0.1 × 0.8²)·ω, so ω ≈ 1.38 rad/s and the clay moves at ω × 0.8 ≈ 1.10 m/s, not the 0.62 m/s you get from linear momentum.
- After the hit, ½(I + m·d²)ω² = (m·v·d)²/(2(I + m·d²)), which keeps only m·d²/(I + m·d²) = 0.064/0.464 ≈ 13.8% of the energy. About 86% turns into heat and sound as the clay squashes.
- The pivot feels nothing when the rod’s own turn and its sideways shove match: that happens at the center of percussion, d = I/(M·L/2) = 2L/3 ≈ 0.67 m. It’s the “sweet spot” of a bat or a hammer.
- With a perfect bounce the ball’s angular momentum reverses instead of stopping: ω = m·v·d·(1 + e)/(I + m·d²) = 2 × 1.38 ≈ 2.76 rad/s. Bouncing hits spin things up more than sticky ones.
- Momentum before: 0.1 × 8 = 0.80 kg·m/s. Just after: the rod’s center moves at ω·L/2 and the clay at ω·d, giving 1.2 × 0.69 + 0.1 × 1.10 ≈ 0.94 kg·m/s. The pivot supplied the difference, about +0.14 N·s.
About the model
- The rod is uniform (I = M·L²/3 about its end) on a frictionless pivot; the lump is a point mass. The hit is instantaneous: during it only the pivot’s force and the contact force act (gravity’s impulse over the ~ms contact is neglected).
- Angular momentum about the pivot is conserved in the hit because the pivot force passes through the pivot. Linear momentum is not: the pivot’s impulse J = p_after − p_before is shown (positive = in the lump’s direction).
- Restitution e: 0 = clay that sticks, 1 = a perfectly bouncy ball. ω = m·v·d(1+e)/(I + m·d²). The center of percussion 2L/3 (zero pivot impulse) does not depend on e or the lump’s mass.
- The lump is launched so that its projectile arc peaks exactly at the hit point, so it arrives horizontally at speed v. A bounced lump then falls as a projectile to the floor and stops (no bounce on the floor).
- After the hit the rod (plus stuck clay) swings as a physical pendulum without friction (RK4 on a 0.5 ms grid, turning point found by bisection). The run ends at the top of the swing, or when a bounced ball lands, or after 3 s if the rod loops over the top.
- The lump is drawn larger than a real 0.1 kg lump so it can be seen; arrow lengths are not to a fixed scale.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.