What you’ll explore
Why does a comet race past the Sun and crawl far away? In this lab you follow Halley’s comet around the Sun and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Fast and slow. Halley’s comet: closest to the Sun at 0.59 AU, farthest at 35.1 AU. How many times faster is it at its closest point than at its farthest?
- How long is a year?. Halley’s orbit has a semi-major axis of 17.8 AU (Earth’s is 1 AU, 1 year). How many years does one orbit take?
- Stretch the orbit. Set the eccentricity so the body is exactly 9 times faster at its closest point than at its farthest.
- Real-world check: Halley at the Sun. At its closest point, 0.586 AU from the Sun, how fast is Halley’s comet moving, in km/s? (Earth orbits at about 30 km/s.)
- Equal slices. Shade the area swept in one twelfth of an orbit around the closest point, and one twelfth around the farthest point. Area near the Sun ÷ area far away = ?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- At the two ends of the orbit the velocity is at right angles to the line to the Sun, so equal areas per time means r × v is the same: v_close / v_far = r_far / r_close = 35.1 / 0.59 ≈ 60.
- Kepler’s third law: T² ∝ a³. With a in AU and T in years, T ≈ a^1.5 = 17.8^1.5 ≈ 75 years. Halley was last near the Sun in 1986 and returns in 2061.
- The ratio is r_far / r_close = (1 + e) / (1 − e). Setting it to 9 gives e = 8/10 = 0.80.
- Vis-viva: v² = GM(2/r − 1/a). At r = 0.586 AU with a = 17.8 AU this gives about 54.6 km/s, almost twice Earth’s speed. At the far end it drops below 1 km/s.
- Kepler’s second law: a line from the Sun sweeps equal areas in equal times. Near the Sun the slice is short but covers a wide angle; far away it is long and thin. Same time, same area.
About the model
- Two-body Kepler orbit: the Sun is fixed at one focus. Pulls from the planets (which make Halley’s period vary between about 74 and 79 years), outgassing and relativity are ignored.
- Position against time comes from the exact solution of Kepler’s equation M = E − e·sin E (Newton iteration), so the orbit never drifts and the time step does not matter.
- Halley’s comet: a = 17.834 AU, e = 0.96714 (JPL). Its orbit is tilted 162° (it goes round “backwards”); here it is drawn in the plane of the screen, counter-clockwise.
- GM of the Sun = 1.32712440018 × 10²⁰ m³/s²; 1 AU = 1.495978707 × 10¹¹ m; time in Julian years.
- The comet is already on its orbit when the clock starts (a naturally moving setup).
- The Sun and comet markers are enlarged (the real Sun is only 0.005 AU across). Shaded slices are equal-time slices; their areas are measured numerically from the drawn positions.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.