What you’ll explore
Why does only one ball fly out? In this lab you newton's cradle and test your intuition against a real physics simulation.
Challenge levels
- Two in. Pull back two balls together and let go. How many balls fly out the other side?
- How fast out?. One ball is released from 30° on a 15 cm string. How fast does the last ball leave, in m/s?
- The energy bill. What if two balls left at half the speed instead? Momentum would still balance. What fraction of the incoming energy would they carry? (1 = all of it)
- A real cradle. Real steel balls aren’t perfectly bouncy. Choose the restitution e so that after 3 seconds the cradle keeps between 70% and 80% of its energy.
- How high?. Release one ball from 3.0 cm above its lowest point. How high does the last ball rise, in cm?
Key ideas
Show the explanations (spoilers: try the levels first)
- Momentum and energy must both come out the same. Two balls in at speed v can only balance both as two balls out at speed v.
- It arrives at √(2gL(1 − cos 30°)) ≈ 0.63 m/s and the last ball leaves at exactly that speed; the three middle balls just pass the momentum along.
- Kinetic energy grows with speed squared: 2 × ½m(v/2)² = ¼mv², half of the ½mv² that came in. The ghost pair (amber) only rises a quarter as high, so it can’t happen.
- Each impact keeps a fraction e² of the energy of the relative motion. With 4 impacts per strike and about 8 strikes in 3 s, even e = 0.99 loses a quarter of the energy — and the middle balls start to drift.
- All the energy arrives in the last ball, so it rises to the same 3.0 cm (with perfectly elastic balls and no air).
About the model
- Five identical steel balls (25 mm, 64 g) on 15 cm strings, just touching at rest. Each swings as a full nonlinear pendulum (RK4 on a fixed 0.5 ms grid); the first strike lands a quarter of the exact elliptic period after release (checked to 1e-8 s).
- Impacts use the "tiny gap" model: instantaneous 1D collisions between neighbouring balls, resolved pair by pair until no touching pair is still approaching. With e = 1 this gives the textbook n-in-n-out result; real balls deform briefly (Hertz contact), which this model does not show.
- Collisions are treated as horizontal because they happen at the bottom of the swing (string vertical). Each impact conserves momentum exactly; with restitution e it loses ½μ(1 − e²)v_rel² of energy (μ = m/2).
- The amber "ghost" pair shows the misconception: two balls leaving at half speed. It is drawn for comparison only; it carries half the energy, so it rises a quarter as high.
- No air drag or string friction: energy loss comes only from the restitution e (real steel ≈ 0.95–0.99). Balls are drawn at their real size.
Every number on screen comes from the simulation, and each lab passes automated checks against the physics formulas. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.